Thursday, June 30, 2016

A Trade for Jose Fernandez is Necessary: Here's Why



(Patrick Farell/Miami Herald)

Boy oh BOY, I don’t know about you but I’m tired of seeing this pitching staff getting beaten up.  Look, for what it’s worth this team is performing just about how I thought they would.  Offense was never the question, but the pitching staff was just not strong enough to balance things out despite additions of David Price and Craig Kimbrel.  The Sox had a great run in May where they were literally the best team in baseball, but of course the offensive output was never going to continue forever.  Now the team is starting to expose themselves, dropping 7 of their last 10 to hand them three straight series losses (two of which to very mediocre teams). 

Over the offseason the Marlins seemingly made fools of themselves with an offer to the Red Sox that would send Jose Fernandez to Boston in exchange for basically everybody that had even an ounce of talent in them.  Obviously the deal was rejected at the time and laughed at by many.  But here we are, in need of that pesky little thing called pitching again and Jose Fernandez may just be the guy to end the woes. 

The Marlins in general have definitely not gotten the credit they deserve this season though, finding themselves right in the middle of the playoff picture.  As a disclaimer to this blog, the Marlins may not even be selling Jose Fernandez at the deadline if they have a chance to make the playoffs, likely through the Wild Card.  But what if they’re out of it by then? Here’s five reasons why the Red Sox should make a move for Fernandez if he’s available.  

5. The average age of the other four is 30.


I know the Mets have suddenly become the poster child for young pitching rotations and there’s obviously no way to parallel that.  But there is something to be said for having guys that are not only young but also developed.  The four current everyday Red Sox starters have an average age of 30 (unfortunately for obvious reasons they don’t have an everyday fifth starter) which is not necessarily a bad thing, its just not the most ideal thing in the world.  Again, what the Mets have is special, but there is no harm in at least trying to get younger.  Fernandez is just 23 and already possesses Cy Young talent, something that could be very deadly to compliment a proven pitcher like David Price.

4. He is under control through 2018.


Speaking of Fernandez’ age, he also comes with a couple more years of service.  2018 will mark his sixth year in the MLB, after which he will hit the open market.  The two youngest everyday starters on the Red Sox, Price and Porcello, are both locked in through at least 2018.  Adding a third arm who can pretty much be paid less than he is currently worth for another two years seems like a very attractive option going forward, especially if this rotation is ever going to try to get back to at least above-average.

3. He is a great second half pitcher.


What’s an opinion without facts? Obviously the second half is a tad bit shorter, but Fernandez is just about as good as you can possibly be during that time.  He has a 2.11 ERA and nearly 150 strikeouts in just 120 career innings in the second half. He’s only lost twice.  Now depending on the circumstances in a month, if the Red Sox are still looking to salvage a playoff spot, they should add a reliable arm that has had success in August and September. These two months are what playoff races hinge on and as Mike Lowell said on MLB Network the other day, you need two, maybe three aces on your staff to make a playoff run.

2. The future is now.


It’s really a pet peeve of mine when people don’t realize that you have to spend big to acquire big time talent.  Miami isn’t going to offer Fernandez up for just a pair of prospects for a lot of the reasons I previously listed.  That being said, Miami wants basically the city of Boston for him and rightfully so.  The Sox are stacked down on the farm with position players, but have jack shit for pitching.  A lot of positional talent has already blossomed at the big league level though (i.e. Betts, Bradley, Bogaerts, etc.). 

Many have bought into this team as a playoff team.  You really think so?  Let’s put it this way, say they’re right on the border (which in fact they just about are).  Dombrowski didn’t go out and sign Price and Kimbrel to look forward to next year because he knows Red Sox Nation is a community of instant gratification. He wants what we want: a 2016 World Series victory.  If there's a chance to make something happen, the time to do it should be now.

So what am I trying to say here? You can’t have it both ways guys.  You can’t argue to “save prospects for the future” when the future is staring you right in the face. So much young talent has come together at the same time and their offense has proved they can compete. You bought into this team as a playoff team, so recognize what has to be done in order to not only get this team to October, but also make a run into late October. 

Among others, here’s what I’m comfortable giving up for Fernandez (any sort of combination):

            Jackie Bradley Jr. He’s relatively the least valuable player of the         Betts/Bradley/Bogaerts trio because he’s not as consistent and is the oldest by three years.

            Andrew Benintendi: He’s a Major Leaguer next year, but he’s not the only outfielder out there if you know what I mean.  He can be replaced; a guy like Jose Fernandez cannot.

            Yoan Moncada: I honestly don’t want to give him up but as the #1 prospect in the system he’s a vital chip to throw into the pot if you want to keep Betts and Bogaerts from moving to South Beach.
 
            Rafael Devers: Another great prospect but Travis Shaw is the guy at third base, so Devers virtually has no place to go for the next few years.

            Eduardo Rodriguez: He’s scuffling so his value is low, but he definitely has potential in him. Maybe a change of scenery might be good for him? Miami will also need to fill a spot in the rotation.

            Clay Buchholz: Lol

In reality Miami will probably reject right away when they see Betts and Bogaerts aren’t involved. A guy can dream though right?

1. He has that “it” factor.



The Red Sox have generally had a poor track record recently when it comes to developing home-grown pitching.  The last really successful guy to come through the system was Jon Lester.  Before that...jeeze...Clemens?  Bottom line, there’s nothing to fall back on right now.  The Red Sox have an opportunity to land a pitcher who has a quality about him that I haven’t seen in a Boston uniform since Pedro Martinez.  He’s young, he’s fiery, he’s competitive, his stuff is ELECTRIC, and he has the talent to carry this pitching staff along with David Price.  This next month should be interesting.

No comments:

Post a Comment